Melee clarification, please
Posted: Sun Jan 07, 2024 11:04 pm
Good evening,
Here's hoping the 2024 is off to a good start for everyone who frequents this forum.
Treading carefully, it promises to be an interesting year . . .
To the point.
In a current scenario (Punic Wars - fictional battle, no refight), the following happened:
A unit of Red's javelin cavalry moved into flank contact with a unit of Blue's Bad Horse. The melee was a tie.
In the next turn, a unit of Skirmishers from a nearby Blue formation was able to move up and take the Red javelin cavalry from behind.
It was Blue's bound, they were the active side. How does the melee resolve?
1 - Is the Skirmisher unit the main attacker against the backs of the enemy horse?
2 - Is the Skirmisher unit simply support for the ongoing melee, where the Bad Horse is flanked and so, at a disadvantage?
Going to attempt a "drawing" here to add some context.
S X
S X Y Y Y
S X
Where S = Blue skrmishers; X = Red javelin cavalry, and Y = Blue bad horse
Thanks in advance.
Chris
Here's hoping the 2024 is off to a good start for everyone who frequents this forum.
Treading carefully, it promises to be an interesting year . . .
To the point.
In a current scenario (Punic Wars - fictional battle, no refight), the following happened:
A unit of Red's javelin cavalry moved into flank contact with a unit of Blue's Bad Horse. The melee was a tie.
In the next turn, a unit of Skirmishers from a nearby Blue formation was able to move up and take the Red javelin cavalry from behind.
It was Blue's bound, they were the active side. How does the melee resolve?
1 - Is the Skirmisher unit the main attacker against the backs of the enemy horse?
2 - Is the Skirmisher unit simply support for the ongoing melee, where the Bad Horse is flanked and so, at a disadvantage?
Going to attempt a "drawing" here to add some context.
S X
S X Y Y Y
S X
Where S = Blue skrmishers; X = Red javelin cavalry, and Y = Blue bad horse
Thanks in advance.
Chris